Score Stream
The Press Box Sports

eBay Alternatives to Selling Sports Cards Online

When someone mentions selling sports cards online, eBay is usually the first site many people think of. It still is the largest marketplace and has the most traffic, but with more and more fees along with many other options coming available, it has lost some ground. When you include shipping costs along with eBay and PayPal fees, many sellers are looking for other alternatives to sell some of their collection. Don’t get me wrong. I have had tremendous success selling on eBay in the past and I look to do the same in the future. However, eBay just isn’t the right place for many sellers and buyers alike. Here are some alternatives if you want to sell online, but would rather avoid eBay.

Check Out My Cards:

All cards with photos and in one location along with $3 flat rate shipping makes COMC a great online marketplace.

COMC has been making a lot of headway in the card market since it’s emergence on the scene. The best feature that COMC offers that many sellers love is that they do a lot of the work for sellers. You complete the submission form and pack up all of the cards you want to sell on their website. They’ll process the order (can take several weeks), they’ll take photos of every card (front and back) and when it’s all processed, you can go in and set prices for your items. They also will handle all shipping so sellers won’t be bothered by packing and mailing out the cards. The fees can get expensive, but someone else is doing the work for you and they have remarkable traffic. The site is very appealing to buyers and more buyers equals more sales. Many sellers are opting to sell their cards with COMC. The search feature is very easy and in depth for buyers which means they could find your cards easier. Run a few sales or try to sell your whole collection in one swing. You can do it all on COMC.


Not always the case, but groups that have over 2,000 members usually are more active and you’ll see better success in these groups.

Facebook has became a hot spot to sell cards for one very big reason. No seller fees. Many sellers are taking advantage of that as there is an estimated 19,000 active sports card groups on the site. The downside to Facebook for buyers is that there is a far better chance to get scammed and customer service from the seller usually is lacking, but as long as buyers pay with PayPal goods, they have similar buyer protections to eBay. As a seller, always get a tracking number when shipping and send it to the buyer quickly. Buyer traffic can almost rival eBay, but with a lot of sellers, comes a lot of competition. If you price your sports cards competitively, provide quick shipping, and great communication with the buyer, Facebook could be an enjoyable and successful way to sell your sports cards.


Sportlots offers a wide variety of cards and many at great prices.

Sportlots has it all. A marketplace to list and sell all of your cards and you can also list auctions. The fees are a fixed rate and and Sportlots gives fee discounts to sellers who sell a lot of volume and list higher valued cards. This is done to encourage better valued cards and low prices. To discourage “fly by night” sellers with unlawful intentions, Sportlots will pay the sellers each month what they’ve earned. So there’s a less chance of a buyer getting burned. They also have a good remedy for Paypal’s 30 cent flat fee. If a buyer purchases cards from five different sellers, the PayPal flat fee is divided between all five sellers. As long as you provide good customer service, ship quickly, and don’t mind getting paid once a month, Sportlots is a great option for sellers. Traffic is really good on this site as there are a lot of sales being conducted. This is my favorite place to buy and sell sports cards. Some sellers have over a million trading cards listed and are very successful in selling their sports cards on the site.

Blowout Forums:

Blowout is very similar to Facebook. It has a ton of buyers and sellers on the site and is a great place for collectors to find a specific card they’re looking for. As long as buyers pay with PayPal goods, it’s safe. No seller fees make it another popular place for selling cards. However, there are some differences in the layout as compared to Facebook. Blowout Forums to me is better organized which makes it easier to browse cards of your liking. If you’re looking for a baseball or football card box break, everything is categorized and makes it easier to browse to find what you’re looking for. This convenience helps sports card sellers out a lot as well.

Sports Card Direct: 

While Sports Card Direct isn’t as popular, it does have a solid interface and gives sellers a lot more control over their marketplace.

This site uses a fixed rate format to sell cards. You can list 100 cards for $4.99 a month, unlimited cards for $9.99 a month or unlimited cards for $99.99 a year. The site is more like a broker so you’ll have to go through your paypal settings to offer multiple card shipping discounts, but the site has a very informative video to help new sellers. Listing cards is quick and simple. The site also makes it easy for buyers to search a certain sellers inventory. Sports Card Direct also offers a free month trial so you can try before you buy! Traffic on this site isn’t as good as other sites, but proper promotion and competitive prices could make this site a success for you. The main obstacle is the search feature is not as user friendly for buyers to find what they are looking for. As long as you take good pictures, offer competitive prices and good customer service, this site has potential to be a great place to sell sports cards online.


Listia gives sellers a unique alternative to sell with their credit system.

The first thing you’ll notice about Listia is that you don’t sell items for money, but for credits towards purchasing other products. You can list products in either auction or buy it now formats. The fees are minimal, but they will take a percentage of credits depending on the final price. You can require someone to pay a few bucks via PayPal for shipping, but it is very unpopular and will hurt your results. If you earn enough credits, you can trade them in for cash value, but Listia will take a percentage. This site is becoming more popular as buyers can actually earn credits through affiliate programs and not having to pay anythin for credits. An excellent site for getting rid of unwanted base and common cards. You can exchange credits for cash for a small fee. Listia can be profitable to you for selling sports cards, but it does require a good bit of work. You can also get good deals on sports cards on the site and flip them elsewhere. ¬†Definitely an alternative to look into.

Here is a few of my scores off Listia.


There is also numerous online retailers you can sell to, but these are some of the best alternatives if you want maximum profit from your cards. Remember, results will vary and depend on how well your service is along with pricing. Many new sellers to a site price way too high thinking buyers don’t know any better. They do and you will leave a negative impression from the beginning. So the more fair and reasonable you are, the more successful you will be selling anywhere online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

two × 5 =